Home     Writers     Op/Ed     Book Reviews     News     Bookstore     Photoshops     Submit     Search     Contact Us     Advertise  
  You are here: 

Sun

12

Oct

2008

Colombia: the High Cost of Free Trade
Sunday, 12 October 2008 11:29
by James McEnteer

Colombian President Alvaro Uribe came to Washington last week – along with a huge retinue to lobby Congress - seeking a Free Trade Agreement with the United States.  He picked a bad time.  Legislators were preoccupied with the meltdown of financial markets.  But Congress may reconvene after the November to deal with fiscal questions.  And in that lame duck session, with nothing to lose and nobody watching, lawmakers may decide to approve a free trade pact with Colombia

The Bush White House has pushed hard to get the deal approved.  In a “fact sheet” press release the Bush administration calls the agreement “essential to our national security.”   Not only will the free trade pact “bring economic gains for both countries” but it will send “a clear message to the region.”

But like the pre-Iraq war intelligence, the “facts” in the White House version of Colombian events have been bent to fit the policy.  Bush claims that “Under the leadership of President Uribe, Colombia has been a strong and capable partner in fighting drugs, crime and terror.”  In reality, despite billions of U.S. dollars earmarked under Plan Colombia to fight illegal drugs, more cocaine than ever is cultivated and exported to the United States from that country.
 
Though ineffective in eliminating cocaine production, the eradication campaign has driven millions of small farmers from their land.  Colombia has more than two million internal exiles, citizens displaced from their traditional farmlands, impoverished and forced to move to cities.  Fumigation has also caused major environmental degradation in many prime agricultural areas.   

Uribe’s “crime fighting” has also been disastrous.  With the assassination of Alexander Blanco Rodriguez in front of his co-workers on August 26, more union members have been murdered in 2008 (41) than in all of 2007 (39).  More trade unionists have been murdered in Colombia in the past five years than in the rest of the world combined.  Chiquita Brands recently paid a $ 25 million fine for hiring paramilitary hit squads to kill union leaders fighting for decent wages and working conditions.   Prosecutions of these murders are rare. 

As an anti-terrorist, Uribe also deserves low marks.  The Colombian Army, along with mercenary paramilitary forces, have acted as terrorists, forcing farmers and indigenous peoples from lands coveted by Mr. Uribe’s corporate clients and friends.  True, the leftist guerillas are a menace.  Average citizens are often caught in a deadly crossfire between the military and the FARC.  But the Colombian army has acquired the habit of dressing up the corpses of their victims with weapons and clothing to make them appear as guerillas, - a practice known as creating “false positives” - instead of merely inconvenient civilians.  This exaggerates the leftist menace and justifies the army’s own murderous violence.

Unfortunately, launching Plan Colombia in 2000, President Clinton waived the provisions of the Leahy Law, prohibiting military aid to governments which permit human rights violations with impunity.  Given Colombia’s abysmal record under Uribe, it is past time for Congress to rescind that waiver.  Otherwise “the clear message” Bush wants to send to Latin America is that the United States cares little for human rights or environmental protections if the return on corporate investment is high.

Republican presidential candidate John McCain has also pledged his support for Mr. Uribe and for the Free Trade Agreement with Colombia.  But his judgment in this instance – as in others – seems hasty and ill-considered.  Unlike McCain, who spent less than a day in Colombia, in the Caribbean tourist haven of Cartagena, I recently spent two weeks traveling from Bogota through several Colombian states, in provincial cities and small towns, talking with farmers and workers and families of victims who had disappeared or been murdered.  No one with whom I spoke thought the Free Trade Agreement was a good idea.  Why not?

Such a pact would only signal U.S. approval for the widespread violations of human rights under the Uribe regime.  More Colombians – especially indigenous peoples and small farmers – would be murdered or driven from their lands.  Many millions more acres would be despoiled by fruitless fumigation.

Until Uribe, or a more principled successor to the Colombian presidency, can demonstrate respect for human rights, environmental protections and the rule of law, Congress should reject a Free Trade Agreement with Colombia.  Just say no.



James McEnteer is the author of Shooting the Truth: the Rise of American Political Documentaries (Praeger 2006).  He lives in Cochabamba, Bolivia. 
More from this author:
The Pain And Power Of Memory (3367 Hits)
by James McEnteer - Cali, Colombia It looks like just another store front in this burgeoning city of two and a half million people in...
The Crime of Incumbency (3854 Hits)
by James McEnteer In poll results released Sunday, Rasmussen Reports says that 59 % of American voters would like to replace the entire...
McCain Flames Out - Brokaw Burns Viewers and Self... Can Obama Pilot a Phoenix? (4107 Hits)
by James McEnteer According to Tim Dickinson’s informative Rolling Stone biography, John McCain crashed three airplanes in his career as a...
The Year of Unreliable Witnesses (3563 Hits)
by James McEnteer Joe The Plumber, aka Samuel Wurzelbacher, has become a kind of bellwether for the 2008 presidential campaign, though it is...
The Times Comes Out for Corporate Profits over Human Rights (2489 Hits)
by James McEnteer The New York Times November 18 editorial urging passage of a free-trade agreement with Colombia is factually challenged and...
Related Articles:
America is No Longer Free (12128 Hits)
by Paul Lehto Habeas corpus -- it's your most fundamental legal right, your right to go to a court and get an order requiring the...
Double Standards in the Phony War: Small Errors Cost Big Bucks, but Enormous Lies Remain Standing (6476 Hits)
by Winter Patriot Here's something you don't see every day! Papers compensate man wrongly implicated in alleged bomb plot: A group...
The Cost of Islamophobia (6764 Hits)
By William Fisher Five years after the terrorist attacks of September 11, 2001, “Islamophobia” -- intensified by the war in Iraq and...
Dangling from a high (4734 Hits)
Click for full image after page loads David Howell was born in 1972 in Elmhurst, Illinois. He started drawing shortly afterwards. In...
You're blowing my high (5485 Hits)
by Frank Pitz The Democrats are in session, will they blow us all off or will they maintain our high? “You’re blowin’ my high” ...


Add this page to your favorite Social Bookmarking websites
Trackback(0)
Comments (0)add comment

Write comment
smaller | bigger

busy
 

adsense

Top