Home     Writers     Op/Ed     Book Reviews     News     Bookstore     Photoshops     Submit     Search     Contact Us     Advertise  
  You are here: 

Sun

02

Nov

2008

The Year of Unreliable Witnesses
Sunday, 02 November 2008 14:52
by James McEnteer

Joe The Plumber, aka Samuel Wurzelbacher, has become a kind of bellwether for the 2008 presidential campaign, though it is clear that he has his own (semi-hidden) agenda, his own (semi-hidden) secrets and his own (semi-hidden) reserves of ignorance. This “average guy” from Ohio is now stumping for John McCain, claiming that an Obama presidency would turn this country socialist and mean “death to Israel.”

Such transparently poisonous nonsense would seem ludicrous on its face to all but the most deluded partisan right-wing warriors. But McCain – who surely knows better – is courting and grooming “Joe” as an attack dog, to say things the candidate himself prefers not to utter.

By accosting Obama on a public street, thus making it into the news cycle, and then becoming a point of contention in a presidential debate, Wurzelbacher ascended from a well-deserved obscurity to fifteen minutes at the pinnacle of presidential politics as an apparent arbiter of common taste: the Average Joe. But his inflammatory views make him more pox than vox populi.

Joe is but the latest and least vetted of many incredible opinionators who commandeer media platforms in this campaign from which to bestow their “wisdom.” Media outlets pay big bucks to individuals who have disgraced themselves or disgraced the system or simply failed upwards from unsuccessful political careers to paid punditry.


We have a minor tradition of convicted felons turning to media for a living. Oliver North and Gordon Liddy are examples of political abusers, crooks and liars who now offer their opinions as talk-show hosts. As long as they have an audience their employers will keep paying them. But who in the world listens to those clowns?

Karl Rove has probably done more to demean and subvert the democratic processes in the United States than anyone in recent memory. He has slandered opponents, politicized government and promoted war as a campaign tactic. He has flaunted Congressional subpoenas with apparent impunity. Some hail his political “genius” for getting George W. Bush into office twice. But Rove has no moral credibility.

We don’t need to ask Rove the question Joseph Welch put to Senator Joseph McCarthy: “Have you no decency, sir? At long last, have you left no sense of decency?” We already know he does not. But instead of answering for his many crimes in Congress or in courts of law, Rove pontificates about Obama’s fitness for office or McCain’s campaign strategies for megabucks on the Fox network and in the pages of The Wall Street Journal. Why would anyone trust anything this scumbag has to say?

Unlike Karl Rove, Robert Shrum has not undermined the democratic system with illegal or mean-spirited tactics. But neither has he won any of the various Democratic presidential campaigns he has advised over the years. Yet here he still is, after publishing his memoir entitled No Excuses, offering advice to candidates and voters alike through The Huffington Post and various op-ed pages. Why should anyone listen?

And why should anyone pay attention to William Kristol, the neo-con sage whose track record on issues makes Shrum look Solomonic? Kristol has wrought more than enough destruction as a cheerleader for the misbegotten Bush-Cheney junta wars in the Middle East. He apparently pushed for Sarah Palin as McCain’s vice presidential candidate. Do we really need to hear more from this discredited bozo in the pages of The New York Times? Enough already.

Assessing the veracity and gravitas of most radio and television commentators, we are confronted by an appalling paucity of perceptive political observation. Fox offers nothing but white noise, in the racial and the aural sense. Talk radio whips ditto heads into emotional frenzies that the “hosts” themselves don’t really share. Their humongous salaries put them in another, higher economic class than the listeners they stir up. Theirs is an exercise in populist cynicism and professional expediency.

We tend to gravitate toward mainstream media and internet sites whose opinions we already share. But the myth of the uncommitted, undecided voter provides a rationale for shrill, outrageous stories and charges that bid to change our minds and our votes. Along with the unreliable mainstream media commentators, the marginal mumbles of Joe the Plumber only add to the uncivil, uninformed babble drowning out any meaningful discussion of urgent issues we can no longer afford to ignore.

James McEnteer is the author of Shooting the Truth: the Rise of American Political Documentaries (Praeger 2006). He lives in Cochabamba, Bolivia and blogs at http://weatherincochabamba.blogspot.com/

More from this author:
The Pain And Power Of Memory (3366 Hits)
by James McEnteer - Cali, Colombia It looks like just another store front in this burgeoning city of two and a half million people in...
Colombia: the High Cost of Free Trade (4472 Hits)
by James McEnteer Colombian President Alvaro Uribe came to Washington last week – along with a huge retinue to lobby Congress - seeking a...
The Crime of Incumbency (3853 Hits)
by James McEnteer In poll results released Sunday, Rasmussen Reports says that 59 % of American voters would like to replace the entire...
McCain Flames Out - Brokaw Burns Viewers and Self... Can Obama Pilot a Phoenix? (4106 Hits)
by James McEnteer According to Tim Dickinson’s informative Rolling Stone biography, John McCain crashed three airplanes in his career as a...
The Times Comes Out for Corporate Profits over Human Rights (2488 Hits)
by James McEnteer The New York Times November 18 editorial urging passage of a free-trade agreement with Colombia is factually challenged and...
Related Articles:
Tomgram: Rebecca Solnit, End of the Year Review, 2026 (6835 Hits)
by Tom Engelhardt, [Note for Tomdispatch readers: With this post, I'm following so many of you offline for the year. I thank each of you who ...
Iraqi Hopes Dim Through Worst Year of Occupation (6698 Hits)
by Dahr Jamail and Ali Al-Fadhily BAGHDAD, Dec. 22 (IPS) - Despite promises from Iraqi and U.S. leaders that 2006 would bring improvement,...
Forecast For the Year Ahead - James Kunstler (11449 Hits)
by James Kunstler Forecast For the Year Ahead First a Look Backward Let's get this out of the way up front: the worst call I made...
New Year Reflections - Ramsy Baroud (5057 Hits)
by Ramzy Baroud 2006 was yet another year of tribulations in the ever tumultuous Middle East. It defied all early expectations that 2005...
The Bombing of the Golden Dome Mosque; one year later (6965 Hits)
by Mike Whitney Bush’s “dirty war” in Iraq has become increasingly violent and confused. The neocon trust in “creative...


Add this page to your favorite Social Bookmarking websites
Trackback(0)
Comments (0)add comment

Write comment
smaller | bigger

busy
 

adsense

Top