Home     Writers     Op/Ed     Book Reviews     News     Bookstore     Photoshops     Submit     Search     Contact Us     Advertise  
  You are here: 

Fri

16

Feb

2007

It’s Got to Be Gore: Part III– There’s No Adequate Alternative
Friday, 16 February 2007 20:45
by Andrew Bard Schmookler

In Part I and II of this series, which can be found here, I suggested that this is an extraordinary time in American history, bringing with it an extraordinary challenge to the next leadership of the United States. The challenge, I suggested, is two-fold: 1) to teach the American people about the meaning of the dark period we have been (and are) going through under the Bushite regime; and 2) to undertake the task of repairing the considerable damage this regime has done to both this country and to the international order.

As the title of this series –”It’s Got to Be Gore”– indicates, I am on my way to arguing that the extraordinary nature of this moment points toward Al Gore as the person on whom we should pin our hopes for leadership to help America respond appropriately to the challenge with which this Bushite era has confronted us.

I expect that, while many of my readers here will tend to agree with me, an equal number will be inclined to reject my conclusion out of hand. Gore has been prominent in American political life for a long while, and is not an altogether unknown quantity. People can look at his record and read it differently, and according to some of those readings the idea that American might turn to Gore at a time when the nation needs GREATNESS in its leadership will seem improbable at best.

In the next installment, I will go more deeply into how I think that record should be read. And in the meanwhile, I simply will ask the skeptical reader to hold that skepticism in abeyance. The Al Gore for whom I will be making the case is one that I believe will be recognizable to all who have followed his career, including his awkwardness and his occasional political flatfootedness in 2000.

I will begin here making the case for Al Gore by considering the three main alternatives to Gore.
(I will not be discussing those declared Democrats who appear to be extremely unlikely to win the nomination. Nor will I consider any of the Republican candidates: until the Republican Party undergoes a serious process of repentance and purge and renewal, that party –which in the last several years has disgraced itself more profoundly than any ruling party in the history of the United States– really cannot be entrusted with the presidency, essentially regardless of its standard bearer.)

***

First, there’s Hillary Clinton. I can think of various reasons why, if we want a president to achieve the various goals I outlined in the first installment, it would not be reasonable to expect Hillary Clinton to be able to lead us there. But I will confine myself to one of those reasons.

One of the goals I proposed, in terms of repairing the damage done by the Bushites, I expressed thus:

** To bring Americans of good will together, rather than work deliberately to drive them apart, as these Bushites continuously have.
This is a task that won’t be easy for any president. But for Hillary Clinton it would be downright impossible. She’s had plenty of time to change the minds of the people who didn’t like her when she was First Lady. But her negatives in the opinion polls are still high, and relatively intense. She simply cannot do what needs to be done.

To put it simply, to overcome the polarization that the Bushites have deliberately created, one ought not turn to a polarizing figure.

It is true that Al Gore also has negatives in the polls, but I believe those negatives to be of an altogether different nature.

First, EVERYONE who goes up against the Bushites gets the character assassination treatment that leads to negative opinions among a sizeable portion of the American public. What are the negatives of John Murtha like, since he had the audacity to stand up and tell it like it is regarding Iraq? (See my brief piece, “Gore and the ‘Right Wing Scream Machine’”.

Second, a lot of people felt let down by the campaign Gore ran in 2000. But a lot has happened in the past six years, including a lot of apparent growth in Gore. But not everyone has paid enough attention to these developments to revise their opinions.

With Hillary, on the other hand, the negative opinions seem to be more visceral and intense, less amenable to revision.

***

Consider next Barack Obama. Obama may be ready to be as splendid a leader as some of his enthusiasts believe. But how can we know with any degree of certainty just what his capacities are for such a position as the presidency? His history is fine, as far as it goes. But it really provides very little evidence that he has the capabilities that are needed in an effective president.

Many people have rightly expressed concerns about Obama’s “lack of experience.” But with Obama the issue of “experience” is not just whether he has been adequately prepared for the office but also whether we, the American people, have enough experience of him to form any reasonably sound judgement of his suitability for our highest office.

If Obama does have the right stuff now for the presidency, is right stuff should become even righter with time, as he becomes better seasoned and better prepared for that job in the years to come. He is young, and will presumably be around for many future presidential cycles. And America will always have need of excellence in the White House.

So maybe Obama WOULD be a good choice now for our next leader. But “maybe” is not good enough at this post-Bushite juncture of our history. Even “probably” won’t do.

With so much at stake, even if we can never have absolute certainty, we really should take as little chance as possible that our next leader will not be up to the job.

***

And the same argument also works against the idea that John Edwards is our best available choice. Yes, he has demonstrated that he’s got the assets required to be an excellent trial lawyer. But that hardly equates to the qualities we need in a leader to provide effective leadership for all the systems the Bushites have damaged.

Probably is not good enough, when we’re at one of those nodes of our history where the direction we take as a society will likely reverberate much deeper into the future than usual.

***

Is it possible that either Obama or Edwards would be a still better president than Gore? Yes, it is possible. I would bet against it, but not with any certainty.

But what I think we can be pretty sure about is this: with Gore, unlike with any of the others, we can be close to certain that the leadership he would provide as president would be GOOD ENOUGH to meet satisfactorily the demands of the occasion.

Gore has already demonstrated a great many extremely relevant capabilities.

In his eight years as Vice President, he gave every indication of understanding how the executive branch works, and of being capable of managing effectively those considerable executive responsibilities entrusted to him. He has more experience in the national legislature than Hillary Clinton, Barack Obama, and John Edwards combined. Most recently, he’s shown an impressive ability both to create a powerful message and to effectively take that message out into the world. (It was announced recently that, as a result of Gore effective diplomacy to advance his message on climate change, British school children will be watching “An Inconvenient Truth” in their classrooms.)

The value of having our next leader being close to certain to be GOOD ENOUGH can hardly be over-estimated. America simply cannot afford to leave the wounds and lingering infections from this Bushite crisis unaddressed by an at least reasonably effective leader.

But there are also some strong and substantial reasons for believing that Al Gore might provide leadership for America that goes beyond “good enough” and enters into the realm of greatness. In the next installment, I will give my reasons for that expectation.
More from this author:
The “Prophetic Social Movement”: Then and Now (6443 Hits)
by Andrew Bard Schmookler On Election Night of 2004, as I lay in bed much of the night awake and miserable, I found myself teetering on the...
The Dems’ New Power: Investigative Hearings Done Right (5649 Hits)
by Andrew Bard Schmookler On Election Day, America took a step that history may show to have been absolutely crucial in saving this republic....
Waging Battle, Building Peace: The Paradox Confronting the Democrats (5849 Hits)
by Andrew Bard Schmookler Confronting the Paradox The goal is no less than to defeat the evil that, in recent years,...
The Dems’ First Step on Iraq: The Kind of Hearings We Need (6158 Hits)
by Andrew Bard Schmookler WHERE CHICKENS COME TO ROOST The Democrats need to achieve two things with respect to the mess in Iraq: 1)...
When Failure is Better than Success: What Americans, and the World, Owe to the Disaster in Iraq (7403 Hits)
by Andrew Bard Schmookler There can be no doubt that the failed American invasion of Iraq has been a terrible thing. Because of...
Related Articles:
Media Sham for Iraq War -- It’s Happening Again (8970 Hits)
By Norman Solomon The lead-up to the invasion of Iraq has become notorious in the annals of American journalism. Even many reporters,...
It’s Not Just Bush: We’re Accountable Too (4838 Hits)
by Heather Wokusch Click on arrow to listen to Heather's Podcast here: www.heatherwokusch.com/podcasts/We_Are_Accountable_Too_48KBs.mp3 ...
Lynching Saddam - Part 10: Virtue, Terror and the Western public opinion’ s bloodthirsty schizophrenia (7155 Hits)
by Gabriele Zamparini, The notorious Kafka-esque trial is over; the Baghdad’s bordello turned its red lights off. Iraq President...
Bush is right, it’s time for America to change course (4425 Hits)
by Ed Kociela The one thing George Bush got right during his speech to the nation Wednesday night is that it is time to change America’s...
If Beal Street Could Talk – Part 1 - Bush's Escalation Speech (6120 Hits)
by David Swanson I'd like to request that nobody shout during this event, and I'll tell you why. I watched Bush's speech with some people ...


Add this page to your favorite Social Bookmarking websites
Trackback(0)
Comments (0)add comment

Write comment
smaller | bigger

busy
 

adsense

Top