Home     Writers     Op/Ed     Book Reviews     News     Bookstore     Photoshops     Submit     Search     Contact Us     Advertise  
  You are here: 

Sat

20

Jun

2009

Where's the Outrage?
Saturday, 20 June 2009 05:47
by Stephen P. Pizzo

First I want to wish you all a happy Watergate Burglary Day. It's been 37-years today, and it seems like yesterday. They just don't make Republicans like that anymore...... (Just kidding.)

Now onto something I struggle with more and more lately. In a nutshell it boils down how everyone of sound mind answers the following question:

Can we be objective when trying to tease truth and justice out of the maelstrom of accusations, claims and mutual violence between Israel and the Palestinians? I grew up watching documentaries of the Holocaust and both documentaries and dramatizations of the Exodus. I remember clearly the first time I saw "those photos" of Nazi death camps. I was a pre-teen and I was shaken to my young, white, suburban gentile core.

Years later I was a green-behind-the-ears radio announcer at teeny, tiny AM station in the boondocks of Northern California. It was June 1967 and the old news teletype machine's bells began clanging more times than I'd ever heard before. I ripped the copy paper out of the machine, cut into the Lawrence Welk music and read the news: Israel's Arab neighbors had launched a joint attack against the fledgling Jewish state. Later that day I remarked that I now knew how the reporters who announced the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor must have felt.

Through all those years, from Israel's founding to that June war, the story has always been about "never again." Jews had been so wronged, for so long, by so many, that it was inconceivable that Jews themselves could do wrong, be wrong or — god forbid — wrong others. How could a people who suffered so simply brush aside becoming the source of the suffering of others? How could they address the unfairness and pain of the great Jewish diaspora by creating a Palestinian diaspora? How could Jews who lucky enough to survived the Warsaw Ghetto, recreate it in Gaza? (And NO, I am not drawing a moral equivalency between the two. I am only recognizing the unsettling similarities that, if the reader is being objective, do apply.)

With rare exceptions the American position on all things Israel has pretty much boiled down to, "Israel, right or wrong." But, despite what anti-Semites like to believe, the reasons for that are far more complicated than AIPAC's poliitcal influence or money. Israel sits smack dab in the middle of the most volatile and strategically important regions in the world. A part of the world where we get much of our energy. A region where US allies are far and few between. You don't just kick your only real friend in that region in the teeth whenever they run amok.

So there's nothing simple about America's relationship with Israel. And visa-versa. America is Israel's talisman, its backstop, its big brother, its security blanket of last resort. And no other nation on earth will do. For good and plenty reasons, Israel views Western European governments the same way a family pet views a member of the family that kicks it every time it gets in range. So it's America Israel turns to whenever the rest of the world makes noises Israel doesn't like.

Anyway, to my Jewish friends, I get it. I always got it. I understand the existential Swords of Damocles — real and imagined — Israelis feel hanging over their collective heads. Having said that though I, and a growing number of other Americans, have also begun to take notice of the suffering of the Palestinians, those bystanders swept aside in world's effort to make amends for it's centuries of antisemitism. It's the other half of the Exodus narrative that's gone untold, or simply ignored, for far too long.


Well, enough from me. The original question stands and remains to be answered: Can Americans of all faiths, points of view, nationalities and political leanings, treat the Israel/Palestine mess objectively?

We must of course. But can we? As one side gins up accusations of growing American antisemitism, and the other side accuses us of being in the "Zionists" pocket," can we? In a situation where both sides have committed the some of the ugliest behavior since World War II, can we treat each with respect and deference where appropriate, and unambiguous condemnation when our inner Jimmie Crickets whispers, "Now, that's just not right."

Here's an excellent article on that very subject.

Have a nice day.


Why aren't Jews outraged by Israeli occupation?

Haaretz.com

By Antony Loewenstein

During this year's AIPAC conference in Washington, Executive Director Howard Kohr warned the 7,000-plus crowd that the global movement to "delegitimize Israel" was gathering steam.

"These voices are laying the predicate for an abandonment," he said. His sentiments were almost apocalyptic: "The stakes in that battle are nothing less than the survival of Israel, linked inexorably to the relationship between Israel and the United States. In this battle we are the firewall, the last rampart."

The age of Barack Obama has unleashed a global wave of Jewish unease over Israel's future and the Diaspora's relationship to the self-described Jewish state. It's a debate that is long overdue.

Zionist organizations in Australia campaigned loudly in May against the allegedly "anti-Semitic" play Seven Jewish Children, a ten-minute think-piece written by an English playwright accusing Jews of complicity in violence against Palestinians in the Gaza Strip.

A Jewish columnist for The New York Times, Roger Cohen, argued in June that the key word among Palestinians now is "humiliation."

"It's not good for the Palestinians, the Israelis or the Jewish soul," he wrote. The Jewish Week editor chastised him for such views - for "the anger, blame and one-sidedness of his argument" - and wondered "whose heart?has grown brutal?"

An upcoming academic conference at York University in Toronto exploring the "one-state, bi-national solution" to the conflict was slammed last week by Gerald M. Steinberg, chair of the Department of Political Science at Bar Ilan University, for fueling "the vicious warfare and mass terror" against Israelis and Palestinians.

The decades-old ability of Zionist groups to manage the public narrative of Israeli victimhood is breaking down. Damning critics has therefore become a key method of control.

But, writes Salon.com's Glenn Greenwald, a leading Jewish-American blogger, "whereas these smear tactics once inspired fear in many people, now they just inspire pity. They no longer work."

He may be overly optimistic, but alternative Jewish voices are rising who are less concerned with being accused of "self-hatred" or treachery. They see it as their duty to damn what is wrong and not simply support Israeli government policies.

A thinking, more enlightened Judaism is emerging, a necessity in the face of apartheid realities. The cause is human rights, not Zionist exclusion.

Obama's recent speech in Cairo reflected the new Jewish consciousness. American Jews were certainly an intended audience because if it this group that must challenge their conservative spokespeople to undo years of following Likudnik thinking. As a candidate in 2008, the then Illinois senator said that, "there is a strain within the pro-Israel community that says unless you adopt an unwavering pro-Likud approach to Israel that you're anti-Israel and that can't be the measure of our friendship with Israel."

Many Jews in the Diaspora have never imagined anything else; it's been an imagined Israel in their minds for decades. Lawless behavior in the occupied territories is ignored through willful ignorance. Tellingly, the most reliable information about these truths in the West is found online, through blogs and activist Web sites, and not generally in the mainstream media. The gate-keepers are clinging on to the Exodus myths for dear life.

Defining a humane Judaism in the 21st century means condemning the brutal military occupation in the West Bank and resisting the ongoing siege of Gaza.

Jewish-American blogger Phil Weiss, who recently returned from the Strip, quoted a young Gazan saying in dismay: "We are being experimented on."

The Palestinian narrative is routinely ignored or dismissed in the U.S. and beyond. This must change quickly for any chance of peace to break out in the Middle East. However, peace without justice is guaranteed to fail.

After Obama?s speech in Cairo, where which he almost acknowledged the Palestinian "Nakba" without mentioning it by name, most major Jewish-American groups reacted with caution.

The Anti-Defamation League said it was "disappointed that the President found the need to balance the suffering of the Jewish people in a genocide to the suffering of the Palestinian people resulting from Arab wars."

This was code for "Nakba"-denial, as pernicious as Holocaust revisionism.

But the liberal J Street lobby, still clinging to the delusion of a viable two-state solution and a "democratic, Jewish homeland," praised Obama?s "active diplomacy" and claimed that the "overwhelming majority of American Jews" supported an end to the West Bank colonies.

Consistent polls suggest they are right, but the devil is in the detail. Is there real will to back the necessary steps, namely the removal of hundreds of thousands of Jewish settlers in the West Bank?

Co-Author of The Israel Lobby, Stephen Walt, said recently that he couldn't understand why more American Jews didn't realize the cliff Israel was running toward. Did they not see that repression in the occupied territories had defined Israel in the eyes of the world? Perhaps apartheid didn't bother them. Out of sight and out of mind. Benjamin Netanyahu's recent speech at Bar-Ilan University suggested he wasn't too fussed, either.

I recently attended the Salute to Israel parade in New York ? picture 100,000 American Jews marching to celebrate the state, waving flags in praise of the IDF. It was a thoroughly depressing affair. Palestinians didn't exist; they were invisible. The world's biggest public display of pro-Israel feeling had no room for 20 percent of the Israeli population (let alone the millions in the West Bank and Gaza.)

These events are actually a sign of desperate projection, not strength. Mainstream Zionism wants to completely shield Jews from the uncomfortable facts of the Israeli occupation and Palestinian self-determination. Jews were a proud people, a clever people and a victimized people. There was no time to indulge in frivolous Arab trivialities.

But facts have an uncomfortable way of seeping back into view. Colonel Itai Virob, an IDF brigade commander in the West Bank, recently told an Israeli court that, "a slap, sometimes a punch to the scruff of the neck or the chest, sometimes a knee jab or strangulation to calm somebody [a Palestinian] down is reasonable."

Where is the Jewish outrage over this?

Antony Loewenstein is a New York-based journalist and author of My Israel Question.
More from this author:
Predictions for 2007 (6832 Hits)
by Stephen P. Pizzo The War: Jenna & Barbara Bush will not be part of their dad's troop surge. Ditto for any member of the Cheney clan. ...
White House Chess (6384 Hits)
by Stephen P. Pizzo The Washington media spent the holidays trying to guess what the President's new plan for Iraq might be. Meanwhile in the...
Fine Mess You Got Us Into This Time (8016 Hits)
by Stephen P. Pizzo At the moment all the focus is on what George W. Bush is going to do about the mess he's made of Iraq. But the larger...
New Lies Forward (6264 Hits)
by Stephen P. Pizzo Well it's a new year, and you know what that means... time to update the administration's list of stated reasons for it's...
The GOP's Comprehensive Immigration Reform Scam (6829 Hits)
by Stephen P. Pizzo Traditional conservative, William F. Buckley was once asked how he would describe a “liberal.” He thought for...
Related Articles:
Where's the Goddamn Outrage: When It Comes to Labor Laws, We Have a Corporate Crime Wave? (2143 Hits)
by Dave Lindorff A new study of 1004 union organizing drives conducted by the director of labor education research at Cornell University’s...
Where's the Anger as the Wheels Come Off Obama's and the Democrats' Recovery Program? (2094 Hits)
by Dave Lindorff My bank, a small regional institution that was not involved in sub-prime lending, and that was not a recipient of any TARP...
Living in District 9 - South Africans abolished apartheid and will host the World Cup in June. So where's the glow? (7739 Hits)
by James McEnteer South Africans abolished apartheid and will host the World Cup in June. So where's the glow? “The eyes of the...


Add this page to your favorite Social Bookmarking websites
Trackback(0)
Comments (0)add comment

Write comment
smaller | bigger

busy
 

adsense

Top