Home     Writers     Op/Ed     Book Reviews     News     Bookstore     Photoshops     Submit     Search     Contact Us     Advertise  
  You are here: 

Tue

01

Jun

2010

Neve Gordon: Pirates in the Mediterranean
Tuesday, 01 June 2010 21:55
by Neve Gordon Ph.D.

“Why didn’t they greet us with muffins and orange juice?” was my friend’s facetious question after listening all morning to the Israeli media’s coverage of the assault on the relief flotilla heading for Gaza, the navy assault that left nine citizens dead and many more wounded. Like a group of pirates in the Mediterranean, the Israeli navy attacked humanitarian aid ships in international waters, and yet Israeli officials and commentators were totally surprised when the passengers did not receive them with open arms. Going through the talkbacks on news sites, it seems that most Jews in Israel were also taken aback.
 
Later in the day, Foreign Minister Avigdor Lieberman held a press conference, in which he made two revealing declarations. First, he asserted that no country would allow a foreign entity to threaten its sovereign borders.  This claim, however, reveals the basic lie regarding Israel’s Gaza policy.
 
Israel has to decide once and for all whether or not it withdrew from Gaza in August 2005. If it did and Gaza is an autonomous entity as Israel claims, then the attempt on the part of these humanitarian ships to reach the Gaza sea port is not an infringement on Israeli sovereignty. If, on the other hand, Israel considers the flotilla’s entrance into Gaza’s territorial sea line as a violation of its own sovereign borders, then Israel needs to admit that it has never given up its sovereignty over Gaza. Lieberman’s statement discloses, in other words, that Israel has fashioned itself as a unique creature in the international arena: the non-sovereign sovereign. When it suits its interests, the government claims that it has relinquished sovereignty over Gaza, but when it does not, the government reasserts its sovereignty. Lieberman should keep in mind that with sovereignty comes responsibility. Thus, if Israel was indeed defending its borders yesterday morning then as sovereign, Israel is also responsible for the Palestinian people in the Gaza Strip--for their livelihood as well as their security.
 
Lieberman’s second declaration was that the Israeli military is the most moral in the world. No other soldiers, he said, would have dealt in such a forgiving way with the people on board the ships.
 
Lieberman conveniently ignored the fact that according to international law the Israeli soldiers were acting like pirates, since hijacking an unarmed humanitarian aid ship in international waters is by definition piracy.
 
Moreover, his second observation is informed by the lesser evil argument; namely, the Israeli military could have been more brutal and chose not to. As the great Jewish philosopher Hannah Arendt pointed out, "Politically, the weakness of the argument [for lesser evils] has always been that those who choose the lesser evil forget very quickly that they chose evil."
 
Neve Gordon, born 15 June 1965, is a Senior Lecturer and head of the Department of Politics and Government at Ben-Gurion University of the Negev, who writes on issues relating to the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict and human rights. A third-generation Israeli, Gordon did his military service in a IDF Paratrooper  unit, and suffered severe injuries in action at Rosh Hanikra, as a result of which he has a 42 percent disability. During the first Intifada he served as director of Physicians for Human Rights, Israel. He is an active member in Ta'ayush, Arab-Jewish Partnership. He identifies himself as a member of the Israeli peace camp, has described Israel as an 'apartheid state' and supports the Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions against Israel movement.

More from this author:
A West Bank Town’s Struggle to Survive (2596 Hits)
by Dr. Neve Gordon "Jerusalem bulldozer 'terrorist' kills 3 in rampage," read the headline of a CNN article describing the recent...
Refusing to Oppress (2342 Hits)
by Neve Gordon Neve Gordon teaches politics at Ben-Gurion University, Israel. Eighteen-year-old Sahar Vardi is currently in an Israeli...
Settler Violence Leads to the Arrest of Peace Activists (1857 Hits)
by Neve Gordon PhD At dawn the activists arrived. Around thirty Ta’ayush (Arab-Jewish Partnership) and international volunteers came to the...
Obama’s Middle East Challenge (2081 Hits)
by Neve Gordon and Yinon Cohen As Barack Obama enters the oval office he will face a series of daunting challenges. One of these is confronting...
What is Israel's goal? - Israel seems more concerned with electoral politics and restoring its military reputation than stopping the Qassam rockets (2204 Hits)
by Neve Gordon The first bombardment took three minutes and 40 seconds. Sixty Israeli F-16 fighter jets bombed 50 sites in Gaza, killing more...
Related Articles:
Israel’s Occupation by Neve Gordon is a Must Read - Book Review by Jim Miles (3910 Hits)
by Jim Miles Israel’s Occupation. Neve Gordon. University of California Press, Berkeley and Los Angeles, 2008. A must read There are...
The Emperor and the Real Pirates (1888 Hits)
by Michael Collins "Avast!" said Captain Timmy. "X" marks the spot. Our map was accurate. This is the buried...
Neve Gordon: Rachel Corrie's Memory, Israel's Image (2533 Hits)
by Neve Gordon Ph.D. This article was originally published in The Nation. Seven years ago, Rachel Corrie was crushed to death by a Caterpillar...
Neve Gordon - Land of Security Know How (1837 Hits)
by Neve Gordon Ph.D. Since the publication of his UN report charging Israel (and Hamas) with war crimes, Richard Goldstone has been subjected to...


Add this page to your favorite Social Bookmarking websites
Trackback(0)
Comments (0)add comment

Write comment
smaller | bigger

busy
 

adsense

Top