Home     Writers     Op/Ed     Book Reviews     News     Bookstore     Photoshops     Submit     Search     Contact Us     Advertise  
  You are here: 

Tue

25

Sep

2007

A Blogger Atones — and Looks to Journalists for 'Civil Discourse'
Tuesday, 25 September 2007 10:08
by R.J. Eskow

We've just passed that time of year when many among us atone for their misdeeds of the past year. Old habits die hard, and I was going back over the last twelve months to see where I had been out of line. Maybe I have been too harsh from time to time, but if bloggers like me want a model for 'civil discourse' they won't get it from journalists like Charles Lane or Scott Pelley.

Lane, a member of the Washington Post's editorial board, adopts the personal slash-and-burn style of blogs in his nasty personal attack on Dan Rather. Too bad he wasn't concise and witty, like the best of the sharp-tongued bloggers. (I'm not particularly sharp-tongued, and I'm certainly not concise, so there's no ego in that remark.)

David Niewert in Firedoglake finds the most absurd untruth in Lane's piece, and it's a whopper. But the style of Lane's piece is telling enough. He starts off with a ham-handed parody letter from Rather, whose behavior he calls "unbecoming," "ridiculous," and loaded with "firing offenses." The "letter" ends, "Thank you, CBS, for saving me from myself." Lane concludes that "no sensible person," "no sane individual," "no one in his right mind" would do what Rather has done in filing his lawsuit.

Lane is a member of the same editorial board that printed a Michael Kinsley commentary called "Cybercreeps Run Amok: Internet Libertarians Should Learn Civil Discourse."

"Why is the tone of conversation on the Internet, especially about politics, so much lower than in the material world?" asks Kinsley. "And nasty? Oh my goodness." There you have it: The Editorial Board approved this piece, then ran with Lane's mugging of a distinguished fellow journalist.

Oh, my goodness.

Then there's the Ahmadinejad interview conducted by Scott Polley on CBS. I'm not going to defend Ahmadinejad's policies — especially since I found myself in the same hotel he and his people were using this weekend, along with a number of other Middle Eastern leaders. Their security measures took out big chunks of my time, and a part of me wanted to say "How about we withdraw this security and let you take your chances like any other tourist?"

Once a New Yorker, always a New Yorker. But the man is a foreign head of state. We are obligated to protect him, and we should allow him to speak at our universities so that his opinions can be heard, debated, and challenged. That's what civilized countries do. And haven't people — especially journalists — learned to question it when one of many unpleasant figures is suddenly singled out for demonization?

As for the Polley interview, Glenn Greenwald and Ezra Klein have covered it, but here's some food for thought. First, note the difference between the treatment Ahmadinejad gets and the way we've handled Moammar Qaddafi. We have proof that Qaddafi sponsored terrorism, including the destruction of the Lockerbie flight, yet the Administration couldn't wait to use the results of negotiations with him to demonstrate that "the War On Terror is working." (Actually, Blair's government simply took advantage of an offer Qaddafi had made years before.)

So why is it acceptable to negotiate with Qaddafi and not with Ahmadinejad? You know the answer to that. But Scott Polley is content to beat the drums for a new war, unrepentant about his profession's role in starting the last one.

Polley's badgering — and his repetition of unproven Administration talking points as if they were established fact — made him look like a Pravda journalist circa 1959. Ahmadinejad, playing to the hometown crowd, took pains to point that out. Recall that over a million Iranians marched in support of the U.S. after 9/11 and you'll realize how much Polley's behavior can set back the cause of progressive reform in Iran.

Polley's performance makes the U.S. look weak and doctrinaire throughout the world, especially in the Middle East — where we should be convincing the public that we're a democracy, not an authoritarian dictatorship.

It's actually fair to say that Polley harmed American national security, by hurting our image among the Arab populations we need to draw to our side. His thuggish, unprofessional performance played right into Ahmadinejad's hands.

Oh, my goodness.

""Cyberspace communities and the cyberspace community at large," wrote Kinsley, "often seem to be more energized by rejecting heathens than by embracing soulmates." Polley's heathen-rejecting performance shows that this phenomenon isn't limited to "cyberspace," much to the detriment of out national well-being.

As for my sins, they're mostly confined to saying harsh things about journalists. I'm sorry about that - although my words don't seem all that bad, now that I see what they consider "civil discourse."
 
More from this author:
Slum Planet, Schrödinger's 'You,' and Other Underreported Stories of 2006 (4626 Hits)
by R.J. Eskow What can you say about a year when the Vice President shoots somebody in the face, hides from the authorities, then gives a...
Iran: The Pale Horse Approaches (5432 Hits)
by R.J. Eskow Sometime in the next several months an announcer will interrupt regularly scheduled programming to introduce the President who,...
Ascensions: Personal Farewells to Alice Coltrane and Michael Brecker (5146 Hits)
by R.J. Eskow Two great musicians, bound together by a thin shining thread, died within 24 hours of one another. Alice Coltrane was a...
Unscientific American: US Almost Last in Understanding Evolution (6157 Hits)
by R.J. Eskow Americans rank next-to-last on a survey of 34 nations' acceptance of evolution as a scientific fact. (See the chart, below.)...
Baghdad Ho! Ann Coulter Discovers It Really Is Just Like LA (4383 Hits)
by R.J. Eskow Critics have called Ann Coulter's comparison of Baghdad to LA ridiculous - but they haven't read her searing "Iraqi...
Related Articles:
Election 2006: Been Down So Long It Looks Like Up To Me (8741 Hits)
by Chris Floyd Ordinarily, the elevation of a gaggle of corporate bagmen, spine-free time-servers and craven accomplices of tyranny and...
Willem Middelkoop looks behind the scenes of the economy (6428 Hits)
A series of conversations between economics reporter Willem Middelkoop and Daan de Wit on current economic affairs. This series is unrelated to the...
See No Evil: Somalia Sinks Into the Pit as the World Looks Away (9785 Hits)
by Chris Floyd How bad is the situation in Somalia, the third target of George W. Bush's "Terror War" take-downs? It's "worse...
Back To The Fab 50s - Ed Naha looks at Globalization (4948 Hits)
by Ed Naha I personally want to thank the geniuses that came up with the concepts of globalization and the out-sourcing of American jobs....
Conviction of Padilla is Bad News for All Americans — Including Journalists (4659 Hits)
by Dave Lindorff With habeas corpus a thing of the past, with arrest and detention without charge permitted, with torture and spying without...


Add this page to your favorite Social Bookmarking websites
Trackback(0)
Comments (0)add comment

Write comment
smaller | bigger

busy
 

adsense

Top