Home     Writers     Op/Ed     Book Reviews     News     Bookstore     Photoshops     Submit     Search     Contact Us     Advertise  
  You are here: 

Thu

04

Dec

2008

Federal Judges Accepting All Expense Paid Junkets to Right Wing Conferences.
Thursday, 04 December 2008 08:13

by Staff

Federal judges were attending corporation-sponsored conferences at posh watering holes, at times on the very subjects of cases they have pending before them, a prominent law school dean wrote in a 2008 book of essays.

While at these sessions, “judges not only hear right wing views propagandized to them, but also hob nob with, speak with, drink with, play golf with, and sometimes even meet on Boards with right wing figures, right wing lawyers, and others who have pronounced right wing views,” said Lawrence Velvel, dean and cofounder of the Massachusetts School of Law at Andover.

“The conferences are paid for by rich right wing foundations – (Sarah) Scaife, of Pittsburgh, Pa., (Charles) Koch, of Arlington, Va. etc.--- and by wealthy, powerful companies involved regularly in litigation where their side is, at minimum, the conservative side,” he said. After attending these sessions, Vevel noted, judges “have been known to go back home and alter rulings on cases on the issues discussed at a one-sided conference.”

Velvel, who formerly worked as a lawyer in the Antitrust Division of the Department of Justice in Washington, said, “one of the reasons antitrust is now of such little value in the U.S. is that the judiciary has adopted views taught at the right wing conferences.”
Writing about the seminars, Dorothy Samuels, a member of the editorial board of The New York Times on January 20, 2006, said the seminars are “underwritten by monied interests out to influence judges to rule in favor of corporate interests on issues like environmental protection and liability for harmful products.”

“Conducted under the innocuous sounding banner of ‘judicial education’,” Samuels added, “(i)n reality these slanted multi-day sessions mock the ideal of an independent, impartial judiciary…”

 


Some justices go beyond what The Times calls “conferenceering” by accepting costly gifts outright. Justice Clarence Thomas was cited by the paper because he “had accepted thousands of dollars in gifts in recent years, including an $800 leather jacket, a $1,200 set of tires from NASCAR, and an extravagant vacation from a conservative activist.”

Velvel said that large corporations and wealthy right wing foundations are not likely to keep pouring money into these conferences---which they call ‘educational’ but which are really transmission belts for unalloyed, unchallenged right wing ideas (read propaganda)---unless they thought a benefit was accruing to them from the conferences. Big corporations pour money into lobbyists to get results, after all. Why would anything less be true of these conferences?”

Efforts to put an end to “conferenceering” were opposed by the late Supreme Court Chief Justice William Rehnquist, on grounds of free speech and the right of judges to get educated. But, Velvel wrote, “The idea here is that ideas and alleged facts are being presented at the conferences, and that to stop judges from attending them, to stop judges from accepting all expenses-paid vactioneering junkets to one-sided right wing conferences, is to deny the judges access to speech and to stifle the operation of the marketplace of ideas. This, to put it bluntly, is unalloyed crap.” Velvel added, “If judges want to find out about a subject, (they can) read a book.”

Velvel said he doesn’t usually write about “the semi-obscenity called the federal judiciary” but when he does it is not favorable because the federal bench as a rule is biased against workers and consumers and traditionally decides in favor of business interests. Velvel’s remarks appeared in his latest book “An Enemy of the People”(Doukathsan Press).

The Massachusetts School of Law is purposefully dedicated to the education of minorities, immigrants and students from modest financial backgrounds that would otherwise not be able to afford a legal education and practice law. The school is known for providing a practical, quality education at about half the cost of most New England law schools. Velvel has been cited by the National Jurist as one of the leaders in legal education reform and has been similarly honored by the National Law Journal. Reach him at velvel@mslaw.edu.

More from this author:
War in Afghanistan Could Doom Obama Presidency (2027 Hits)
by Lawrence Velvel We hope for Barack Obama to have all the success in the world. And given his smarts — he seems far and away the...
The Bigger The Company, The More Disastrous The Mistake (2172 Hits)
by Lawrence Velvel In younger days I was an antitrust lawyer for a considerable number of years. Most of my work, and my cast of mind,...
Move to End Internet Neutrality Seen as Blow to Ordinary Bloggers (1768 Hits)
by Lawrence R. Velvel If the cable and phone companies that transmit Internet data are allowed to charge higher rates to some producers for...
The Four Torture Memos, Eichmann, And The Obama Administration (1689 Hits)
by Lawrence Velvel I have read the four memoranda that were recently released by the DOJ and authorized torture. Permit me to invent a similar...
President O’Bomber Denies CIA Not Connecting Dots On Terrorist Plans (2139 Hits)
by Lawrence Velvel (Satire) In an exclusive interview, President Barack O’Bomber said it was not true “that our (CIA) analysts were not...
Related Articles:
Midterm Elections 2006: It's Always Darkest, Right Before ... It Goes Completely Black (9834 Hits)
by Phil Rockstroh If voting could change the system, it would be illegal. --Theodore Adorno "I can't go on. I'll go on....
The Dems’ New Power: Investigative Hearings Done Right (5735 Hits)
by Andrew Bard Schmookler On Election Day, America took a step that history may show to have been absolutely crucial in saving this republic....
Battling the Right Wingnuts (4418 Hits)
by Ed Kociela Among my loyal readers is a guy named Jack, who frequently sends me those bogus e-mails about all the “good things”...
Tommy Franks Was Right (4507 Hits)
by Larry C Johnson Douglas Feith, the former number three man at Rummy's Department of Defense and co-author of the debacle in Iraq, proved...
Getting It Right on Iran (4076 Hits)
by Larry C. Johnson The truth about the Iranian threat is that the Bush Administration is not telling the real truth. Like any effective...


Add this page to your favorite Social Bookmarking websites
Trackback(0)
Comments (0)add comment

Write comment
smaller | bigger

busy
 

adsense

Top