Home     Writers     Op/Ed     Book Reviews     News     Bookstore     Photoshops     Submit     Search     Contact Us     Advertise  
  You are here: 

Sun

28

Jan

2007

Review: Iraq in Fragments
Sunday, 28 January 2007 21:22
by Muhammad Idrees Ahmad
The realism means that both films are restrained from taking a political stance and depicting the wider context of the events…This lack of "cognitive mapping" is crucial. All we see are the disastrous effects.
Slavoj Zizek on WTC and United 93
In the years since the invasion of Iraq, many documentaries have attempted to record its consequences: the violence; the occupation; the plunder. The focus has ranged from the anthropological to geopolitical, just as the production has varied from the bland to the spectacular. With the urgency of the political reality taking pre-eminence, the myriad documentary renderings have hitherto failed to present a sustained portrait of life in occupied Iraq. Iraq in Fragments –the distilled product of more than two years and 300 hours of filming – is James Longley's splendid contribution towards filling this void.

{youtube}Z39tD1wK6wA{/youtube}
Above, the official theatrical trailer for the documentary "Iraq In Fragments," directed by James Longley, was was the winner of three awards at the 2006 Sundance Film Festival, among many other honours.
The title, like the rest of the film, is open to interpretation: it could be a description of present day Iraq disintegrating into Sunni, Shia and Kurdish fragments; of the internal fragmentation of the Iraqi society; or the three fragments from which the film is constructed. What distinguishes the film from all others, is the hypnotic intimacy that puts the viewer into the heads of Longley's subjects. The stunning cinematography and the profound subjectivity add depth to this masterful work of art.

Muhammad of Baghdad, the first part, follows an 11-year-old Sunni orphan who apprentices for a mechanic while struggling at school. Despite the abuse he has to endure at work, Muhammad continues to look up to the boss, whose frequently cruel treatment is interspersed, at times,with avuncular generosity.

Sadr's South
, the second part, follows Sheikh Aws al-Khafaji, a 32-year-old member of Muqtada al-Sadr's Hawza movement as he organizes local elections to pre-empt the American orchestrated electoral charade designed to give legitimacy to appointed surrogates.Hope, apprehension and fear, in a backdrop of slow burning rage. The insistent beat of the self-flagellation inan Ashura procession could be the rhythm driving the inexorable march of history that carries the Shia, with their new found confidence, towards the dominance long denied them; here is a People asserting its identity in bloody rituals long suppressed under Saddam's imposed secularism.

Kurdish Spring, the third part, follows two families in the almost idyllic setting of Koretan, near Erbil, straddling the contradictions of the promised "liberation and progress" with the tangible reality of their daily lives, yet to see the promises materialize. An appropriately bleak motif is lent the story by the dark billowing smoke ofa brick factory.The deep friendship between the children of the two families develops oblivious to the developing circumstances, even as unemployed men –able bodied, "with big moustaches" –find it harder to ignore as they are turned away from the brick factory empty handed.

In his superb use of Cinéma vérité  techniques, Longley has developed an impressionistic portrait rich in moving detail. By spending endless hours following his subjects without inserting himself into the narrative,he allows their stories to develop organically. The occupation itself receives a second billing where all the references to it are passive.It is clear, however,that the occupation has added another layer of complexity to lives already disrupted by the crippling privation of two brutal regimes: Saddam's; and the US-UK imposed sanctions.

The film's greatest achievement is perhaps also its biggest weakness: the film's intimate focus and the virtual absence of the occupation — except in the occasional ruminations of subjects –fails to take into account its all encompassing embrace. It is the saturated, often dazzling,hues of the beautifully shot images, as much as the endless greys of the narrative that perhaps account for its appeal, which transcends ideological boundaries.The film, in the end, is vague enough that it could serve to reinforce views whether for, or against the war.This might ensure a wider audience for the film,but contributes little to the understanding of what afflicts the subjects, so beautifully humanized in the film.

The immorality of the invasion and occupation of Iraq is unquestionable; there are non-controversial standards — the Nuremberg laws for instance — to judge it by. For all its brilliance, the film scrupulously avoids articulating a position on the occupation. For this – while it deserves each one of the awards it has received, not to mention those, like the Oscar, which it may receive in the future – it remains a compelling work of art, rather than an instrument of political change.

Muhammad Idrees Ahmad is a researcher at Spinwatch. His regular commentaries appear on The Fanonite
More from this author:
Anyone Can Go To Baghdad; Real Men Go To Tehran (8388 Hits)
by Muhammad Idrees Ahmad "Anyone can go to Baghdad; real men go to Tehran", an administration official was heard saying shortly...
From Scotland to Caracas — The Politics of Democracy Promotion (5928 Hits)
by Muhammad Idrees Ahmad The temperature on the night bus from Caracas to Mérida is uncomfortably low. Venezuelans relish the opportunity...
Occupied Iraq: A Horizontal View (Book Review by Mahammad Idrees Ahmad) (10451 Hits)
by Muhammad Idrees Ahmad Beyond the Green Zone: Dispatches from an Unembedded Journalist in Occupied Iraq by Dahr Jamail, Haymarket Books,...
Labour Friends of Israel in the House (4055 Hits)
by Muhammad Idrees Ahmad The Labour Friends of Israel has become a powerful lobbyist for Zionist and Israeli interests in the UK. This article...
There Will Be Blood - Book Review by Muhammad Idrees Ahmad (19595 Hits)
by Muhammad Idrees Ahmad Voice of Hezbollah: The Statements of Sayyed Hassan Nasrallah, edited by Nicholas Noe, Verso, 420 pp., £12.99, 978 1...
Related Articles:
Dear Dubya: The Iraq Solution! (9891 Hits)
Hey there Georgie Boy, long time no speak. From what I’ve been hearing, you’ve had a rough time as of late. As always, I’m here to help. So...
Why Bush Smiles: Victory is at Hand in Iraq (11932 Hits)
Despite George W. Bush's ostentatious bucking up of the Iraqi government yesterday, it is very likely that there will indeed be an...
U.S. Service Academy Graduates Unite Against Illegal Iraq War (12194 Hits)
Atlantic Free Press Netherlands – (October 26, 2006) – The overwhelming response by alumni of United States service academies to the...
The New Media Offensive for the Iraq War (10345 Hits)
By Norman Solomon The American media establishment has launched a major offensive against the option of withdrawing U.S. troops from Iraq. ...


Add this page to your favorite Social Bookmarking websites
Trackback(0)
Comments (1)add comment

a guest said:

0
...
How deeply stirring.
 
January 29, 2007
Votes: +0

Write comment
smaller | bigger

busy
 

adsense

Top