Home     Writers     Op/Ed     Book Reviews     News     Bookstore     Photoshops     Submit     Search     Contact Us     Advertise  
  You are here: 





Friday, 22 December 2006 06:41
by Dave Edwards
The BBC On The Haditha Massacre

The title of the BBC news report was suitably ‘balanced‘: ‘Iraqi Deaths.’ Not ‘American Massacre,’ or ‘American Massacre Of Iraqi Civilians.’

News anchor George Alagiah introduced the piece:

“The US military is preparing to announce charges against a group of marines accused of killing Iraqi civilians. More than 20 people, some of them children, died in Haditha a year ago. But it’s not clear whether they were killed deliberately.”

In May, the New York Times reported that the slaughter was "methodical in nature". (Thom Shanker, Eric Schmitt And Richard A. Oppel Jr., 'Military Expected to Report Marines Killed Iraqi Civilians,' New York Times, May 25, 2006)

The Los Angeles Times reported that many of the victims were killed "execution-style," shot in the head or in the back. A US government official accepted that the US marines had "suffered a total breakdown in morality and leadership, with tragic results". (Tony Perry and Julian E. Barnes, 'Photos Indicate Civilians Slain Execution-Style,' Los Angeles Times, May 27, 2006. See Media Alert)

Iraqi prime minister Nuri al-Maliki has called the Haditha killings a "terrible crime". (‘US Marine captain to face Haditha charges - lawyer,’ Reuters, December 19, 2006)

Known and very popular cialis coupon which gives all the chance to receive a discount for a preparation which has to be available and exactly cialis coupons has been found in the distant room of this big house about which wood-grouses in the houses tell.

But for BBC TV news “it’s not clear” whether the old men, women and children were killed deliberately by American troops.

Washington correspondent Matt Frei’s report began with footage of a military ceremony:

“The US marine corps - square-jawed embodiment of a proud military tradition. So how does this fit in? November 2005, the aftermath of a massacre in Haditha. 24 civilians were slaughtered - the oldest was in his seventies, the youngest three.” (Matt Frei, News at Six, December 21, 2006)

This immediately contradicted Alagiah’s introduction - according to Frei it was a massacre, the deaths +were+ deliberate. The report showed archive footage of the massacre’s sole survivor, twelve-year-old Safa Younis. Frei commented: “She survived by playing dead next to her sisters’ bodies.”

Frei translated Younis’ testimony:

“US marines knocked on our door. My father opened it and they shot him dead. Then they went from room to room.”

Frei continued:

“Haditha was and is a wasteland of insurgent violence. What triggered the shooting spree in 2005 was the death of Lance Corporal Miguel Terrazas, killed after the marine‘s convoy was hit by a roadside bomb.”

This is standard for BBC reporting. Western crimes do not take place in villages and towns, in homes where people live and love and grieve. They take place in “wastelands” filled with murderous savages who have no right to defend themselves against our violence. And as is perennially true of reporting from Palestine, the violence of the West and its allies is always “triggered”, is always a response to “their” violence.

Emphasising the point, Frei interviewed Jesse Grapes, former commander of Kilo Company - the unit accused of the massacre. Grapes was clearly not of the “wasteland”. He was resplendent in smart suit with a US flag draped in the background. Grapes said of Terrazas:

“One of those guys with a million dollar smile. You know, always positive no matter how harrowing the situation. Always hard-working, would do anything that you asked him to do. And you lose someone like that it causes despair.”

Frei’s commentary continued:

“But did despair spawn murder?”

Imagine for a moment if the BBC had been reporting the massacre of 24 British or American old men, women and children by Iraqi troops under Saddam Hussein, or al Qaeda fighters under Osama bin Laden. Would the former commander of the unit charged with the atrocity be invited to explain the suffering and despair that drove his men to kill innocent civilians? Would he be allowed to speak without any challenge from the reporter, without even the mildest of rebukes?

And would footage of a mother embracing one of the accused be shown, as happened next in Frei’s report? A US marine was shown in uniform in Haditha and then hugging and laughing with his family. His mother asked: “You been good?“ The soldier replied: “Ah, I try to be.“

This was Lance Corporal Justin Sharratt, accused of one charge of murder involving unpremeditated killings of three males in a house.

This was followed by an interview with Sharrat’s father, who wept as he spoke:

“Justin told me, ‘Dad, it’s better that we’re fighting in Iraq, in the sands and the streets of Iraq, than in the streets of America.’ And I hope these people understand what these guys are going through.”

Can we possibly conceive of this kind of sympathetic coverage being afforded to ‘enemy’ troops accused of the massacre of British or American civilians? Would comparable words from the father of the ’enemy’ accused be deemed actually monstrous in this case? And, again, there was no journalistic challenge, no balancing commentary to clarify that, by broadcasting these comments, the BBC was not intending to justify or excuse what had happened.

Frei‘s conclusion was almost as remarkable:

“Whatever the charges today, Haditha has left the marine corps and America with a very painful question they thought they’d never have to ask: How and why have the liberators ended up killing the liberated?”

With 655,000 Iraqis lying dead after nearly four years of war, with one million Iraqi civilian dead after 14 years of US-UK sanctions, Frei can suggest that, only now, with this incident, does the question finally arise of how Americans have ended up killing Iraqis.

On the same day that Frei made his comments, Helen Boaden, director of BBC news, wrote to a Media Lens reader:

“I think the key point that I would make in response is that it is not for the BBC to take a view about the legality of the war in Iraq... it is not for the BBC to take a stance on the issue.” (Email to Media Lens, December 21, 2006)

Are we to believe, then, that Matt Frei is not taking a view, not taking a stance, in describing the American armies in Iraq as “liberators” and the Iraqi people as “liberated”?


The goal of Media Lens is to promote rationality, compassion and respect for others. In writing letters to journalists, we strongly urge readers to maintain a polite, non-aggressive and non-abusive tone.

Write to Matt Frei at the BBC
Email: matt.frei@bbc.co.uk

Write to Helen Boaden, Director of BBC News
Email: HelenBoadenComplaints@bbc.co.uk

Write to Peter Horrocks, Head of BBC TV News

Please consider sending a complaint to the BBC
More from this author:
Dangerous Minds (15316 Hits)
by David Edwards "Our complex global economy is built upon millions of small, private acts of psychological surrender, the willingness...
Media Alert: Patriotism as Propaganda (9259 Hits)
by Dave Edwards On December 24, the Independent on Sunday‘s front page featured a portrait of a British soldier gazing pensively into the...
The Locus Of Responsibility (9225 Hits)
by David Edwards In his book Necessary Illusions, Noam Chomsky summarised the stark divide separating media treatment of state crimes: ...
Somalia - A Trip Down Memory Hole Lane (9757 Hits)
by David Edwards Following recent American airstrikes in Somalia, the words ‘Black Hawk Down’ have been mentioned dozens of times across...
The BBC and the 'Harmless' Heat Ray (7789 Hits)
by Dave Edwards General Mann: “That skeleton beam must be what they used to wipe out the French cities.” Dr. Forrester: ...
Related Articles:
Selling Satan: Iraqi War Dead and the Collateral Damage to America's Soul (11831 Hits)
by Phil Rockstroh Headline (Reuters): "United States numb to Iraq troop deaths: experts"   "O Nature, and O...
The New Media Offensive for the Iraq War (14483 Hits)
By Norman Solomon The American media establishment has launched a major offensive against the option of withdrawing U.S. troops from Iraq. ...
Mafia Hit On The Media (16272 Hits)
by John Weaver If I simply stood anywhere near Boris Berezovsky, I’m sure my hair would fall out and my skin would turn yellow. ...
Toronto's Dead Multitudes (7268 Hits)
by Chris Cook A couple of weeks past, a small group of Toronto's citizens observed a grim milestone in Canada's richest city; the marking...
Media Sham for Iraq War -- It’s Happening Again (12279 Hits)
By Norman Solomon The lead-up to the invasion of Iraq has become notorious in the annals of American journalism. Even many reporters,...

Add this page to your favorite Social Bookmarking websites
Comments (6)add comment

Pastor Doodah said:

Dry spin
Well observed. This is the kind of thing that happens every day and we never notice.
December 22, 2006 | url
Votes: +0

DB said:

Makes me absolutely goddamned sick. Matt Frei & his ilk need a good dose of US-style liberation, pronto.
December 22, 2006
Votes: +0

Alan M said:

More Mainstream Media censorship
The Mainstream Media will cover up a story until it can no longer be covered up then they'll produce a skewed story like the above. The media has been bought and paid for. It is getting worse. Censorship is becoming America's favorite past-time. The US gov't (and their corporate friends), already detain protesters, ban books like "America Deceived" from Amazon and Wikipedia, and fire 21-year tenured, BYU physics professor Steven Jones because he proved explosives, thermite in particular, took down the WTC buildings.
Last link (before Google Books bends to gov't will and censors the title:
December 22, 2006 | url
Votes: +0

Dan D. said:

Clearly Matt Frei is one of many journalists in the "free world" fearing for his job if he doesn't write excuse style on a subject like one of the massacres by "liberators" in Iraq. Also he uses the writing style of blaming the death instead of the murderours.
Our press has clearly become some kind of SS-directed propaganda machine.
December 22, 2006
Votes: +0

Andrew Milner said:

Nice country, nice people, shame about the government
Brutal, licentious soldiery. The fall out from the crimes committed by US forces in Iraq will reverberate for decades leading to loss of morale authority, economic and political collapse, pariah nation status. You are looking into the Pit; only an optimist would say the worst is over. In 100 years the reputation of the US will still be besmirched by what happened in Iraq. That's assuming the country currently known as the United States of America hasn't divided into several separate and independent countries, at the will and volition of the majority of the population. Because when the people fully realise how cruelly they were deceived and the crimes committed in their collective name, they will be too ashamed to be American. Nice legacy, George.
December 22, 2006
Votes: +0

Winter Patriot said:

Winter Patriot
Here's hoping you're right, Andrew
when the people fully realise how cruelly they were deceived and the crimes committed in their collective name, they will be too ashamed to be American
And Can It Please Happen SOON???
December 24, 2006 | url
Votes: +0

Write comment
smaller | bigger



Top 123